Boiled Pudding

Takes about
3 hrs 30 mins
, is
Bit tricky
to make, and great for a
Sweet treat
Saint Classic recipes

WHY You'll love

Boiled Pudding

When I think about boiled pudding, I think about the family day on the last Sunday of Scott’s Camp weekend at Thompson’s Hill. Sunday Roasts laid out on picnic blankets followed by hours spent exploring the hills and surrounding woods. Clambering over the ‘St Helena Rock’ before returning for afternoon tea.

The Quality Street tins would all come out filled with coconut fingers, homemade jam tarts, rock cakes and of course the highlight of the afternoon, boiled pudding. Thick slices of pudding served up with custard and hot cups of milky tea.

No items found.


Makes about
15 Servings
Makes about
15 Servings

563 g Plain Flour

225 g Butter

340 g Brown Sugar

226 g Chopped Dates

5 Eggs

2 tsp Baking Powder

2 tsp Mixed Spice

½ tsp Ground Nutmeg Spice

2 tsp Vanilla Essence

1 tsp Almond Essence

Pinch of Salt



Large Pot, Heatproof Plate or Trivet, Linen cloth (We use a cotton pillowcase), Sieve, Bowls, Wooden Spoon, String,



  1. Sieve together flour, baking powder, mixed spice and a pinch of salt in a large bowl.
  2. Rub in the butter until the mixture resembles breadcrumbs.
  3. Add sugar and chopped dates to the breadcrumb mix.
  4. In a separate bowl beat the eggs, vanilla and almond essences together.
  5. Combine the egg mixture to the breadcrumbs to make a stiff ball of dough.  The mixture will be quite sticky to start so resist the urge to mix using your hands,  keep stirring with a spoon until all is combined.
  6. Dampen a linen cloth (or pillow case) and lightly dust with flour.  Place your dough mixture in the centre of the cloth, and gather up the fabrics corners around the pudding dough.  Tie the opening tightly with string, creating a loop handle to easily remove the pudding from the hot water once cooked.  Remember to leave a little space inside to allow for expansion as the pudding cooks.
  7. In a large pot place a heatproof plate (upright) to prevent the pudding from sticking to the bottom of the pot.  Full pot halfway with water and bring to the boil.
  8. Carefully lower the pudding into the boiling water onto your plate and loosely cover with the lid.  Boil/steam for 3 - 3½ hours. Keeping an eye on the water levels, and topping up with boiled water from the kettle periodically if needed.
  9. Once cooked, remove from the pot and carefully unwrap the pudding from the cloth.  allow to cool completely before cutting into thick slices. The cooking process should result in a chewy outer layer and a soft light rich cake pudding inside.  The pudding will darken in colour as it cools.
  10. Serve with hot custard as a desert or have with a cup of tea.

Similar recipes

A little decadent, morrish and so beautifully pimped up jam tart.
2 hrs 30 mins
Water based vegetable which enhances favour.
1 hr
Wholesome heartwarming soup filled with big favours.
1 hr
Super Easy

Explore St Helena Island

Saint Cooks cooking St Helena Island

We're writing a Cookbook

💌  Get our newsletter filled with new recipes, book progress and more...
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.